Shoe Dilemma

Hello everyone!
Today...I want your advice.
But first let me give you the whole story so you understand...

I have been in LOVE with these shoes from Payless. I first tried them on a few weeks ago but their $30 price tag (which I think is kind of steep of Payless) drove me away.
With things I REALLY like..I usually stalk them like crazy until they go on sale.
Eventually these shoes did. They got marked down to $22.99 and there was also a 20% off coupon floating around which I used. That meant my shoes were now around $18-$19! So you can imagine how excited I was!
So I bought the shoes online in 2 colors: Black &Beige
Then I realized I had a $3 off coupon in my wallet! Oh no! So I went to an actual store found the shoes (which they only had in black) and bought them using BOTH coupons!
Joy! Now I'm trying to decide if I really need BOTH colors....
What do you guys think? Both colors? Or no..?

Here are the shoes in black ;)

And here they are in the beige.
I think having the EXACT same shoe in 2 colors is kind of too much..but I really can't decide!
These shoes are REALLY comfy. They are like Naturalizers/Aerosoles in that the insoles are specifically designed to be comfortable.
The heel height is also low...about 1inch? I highly recommend these shoes (click here to buy)
Payless has this great shipping option where they will ship to your local Payless shoe store for FREE! No shipping fees! Here is a link to the 20% off coupon I used.

So? What should I do? Keep both shoes? Keep the beige? Keep the black?
Ahh!!

Cheers!